Olathe has sent a four-story apartment plan back to the city’s planning commission to lower a building, add privacy screening and study traffic impacts more closely.
The Olathe City Council on Tuesday voted 7-0 to send a proposed 476-unit apartment complex near Heritage Park back to the Olathe Planning Commission after the developer agreed to lower one of the buildings.
Rodrock Development want to build seven four-story apartment buildings on about 25 acres northwest of 159th Street and Pflumm Road.
The proposal, called Residences at Heritage Park, includes mostly one- and two-bedroom rental apartments, along with garages, a pool, clubhouse and a connection to Heritage Trail.
The Olathe Planning Commission voted 4-3 last month to recommend approval of required site rezoning and preliminary plans.
The project would sit directly east of the Reserve at Heritage and Symphony of the Reserve neighborhoods.
Neighbors have raised concerns for months about the buildings’ height, traffic and how the apartments would fit next to their single-family homes.
Nearby property owners filed a valid protest petition after the planning commission’s Oct. 12 vote, meaning the project needed at least six “yes” votes from the city council for approval.
In addition to the preliminary site plans, Rodrock Development requested rezoning the site from business park to R-4 medium-density multifamily.
“No more sunrises”

Many of the neighbors’ concerns centered on the building at the northwest corner of the proposed complex.
They say the four-story, 50-foot building would overlook their homes and block their views.
“Fifty-foot buildings in the backyard means no more sunrises. No more big sky,” said resident Joseph Maxwell, who was one of a dozen people who spoke in opposition to the project at the planning commission meeting.
Maxwell and two other nearby residents spoke on Tuesday as well. He said three homeowners associations representing 381 homes sent a letter outlining their concerns.
City staff said rezoning the property from business park to residential would guarantee a lower building at the site. With a business park zoning, buildings can be up to 144 feet tall.
After the residents spoke, Rodrock agreed to lower the furthest northwest building to two stories. They didn’t specify how this would affect the total number of units.
Traffic and neighborhood compatibility
But, reducing the height of the building was only one of the requests the city council made of the developers.
Councilmembers also asked Rodrock to look at how it could better screen the apartments, garages and parking from residences along the west side of the property.
Councilmember Robyn Essex said she had walked the path near the northwest building with residents and was concerned about the abrupt transition from single-family homes to four-story apartments.
“There is no transition,” she said. “It just goes, boom, R-1 to all of a sudden four stories.”
Judd Claussen of Phelps Engineering, who represented Rodrock at the meeting, said the developers would explore more substantial landscaping to add a buffer between the project and existing neighborhoods.
“We’d be happy to take explore that as part of the final plan,” Claussen said.
Councilmembers also questioned how Pflumm and 159th Street would handle more traffic generated from the project.
Nearby resident Carrie DeMaio said Pflumm isn’t ready to take on additional traffic.
“I think it would be wiser to wait until Pflumm’s expanded,” she said.
The development would have three entrances on Pflumm, with turn-lane improvements required at each.
Staff said broader improvements to Pflumm between 151st and 159th streets, however, are not in the city’s Capital Improvement Plan.
Senior City Planner Jessica Schuler said a traffic study projected the apartments would generate about 25% fewer peak-hour trips than the business park development previously approved for the site.
Councilmembers asked for a clearer picture of the possible impact on traffic.
“I would consider how long does it take to get from Mur-Len to Quivira if you’re driving on 159th Street in rush hour,” Councilmember Matthew Schoonover said. “That’s probably more what I would worry about as opposed to how many cars are on the road at any given time.”
Rodrock representative Judd Claussen said the company is invested in the property and the city of Olathe.
“The Rodrock team is a hometown, quality generational builder dedicated to building great communities,” Claussen said. “Not some out of town developer that’s here today and gone tomorrow.”
City council votes
Councilmember Jeff Creighton first raised the idea of sending the project back to the planning commission, giving the developers the opportunity to revise the plans to address the councilmembers’ concerns.
“I think that we could get a better project for the neighbors by the remanding,” Creighton said. “But we have to be very clear to planning commission. I spent a lot of years on planning commission, and there’s nothing more frustrating than sitting up there and not knowing what council wanted.”
The city council directed Rodrock to reduce the northwest building’s height and look into additional screening and effects on traffic.
The planning commission will reconsider the plan at a future meeting.
Keep reading more housing news in the area: The Overland Park Planning Commission last week approved a rezoning request that would make way for $1 million homes also near Heritage Park at 167th Street and Pflumm, eight blocks away from this project.


Thanks for reading! If you value having an independent news outlet keeping tabs on local government, schools and taxes, we're asking you to contribute to our Education Reporting Fund.