Taylor-Made Homefront: Are you a house person or a location person?

Share this story:

By Chad Taylor, the Taylor-Made Team

It’s one of the most important questions I find myself asking when I sit down with potential sellers. Usually, it’s sitting underneath the real concern they have, which sounds more like this: “If we sell, are we actually going to find something else?”

That fear is real. And the answer almost always comes back to how you’re wired as a buyer.

Are you chasing the house or the location?

House people tend to focus on size, layout, and features. They’re willing to move around geographically if it means getting the right setup. Location people are different. They are locked in. It might be a school boundary, a neighborhood, or even a few specific streets. The house matters, but the location wins.

And trust me, I get it. Leah and I are location people through and through.

Several years ago, we moved from a three bedroom, two bath home into another three bedroom, two bath home. For about twice the price. Some people thought we were nuts. But why?

Because for us, it was never really about the house. It was about where that house sat.

We wanted to walk to our elementary school. We wanted to stay in Prairie Village. And we got very specific. Think 63rd to 83rd, between Mission and Roe. That’s not a broad search. That’s basically a few turns and a stop sign.

And it took time. We actually wrote an offer on our current home almost two years before the sellers were ready to sell. So we waited. And waited a little more. Eventually, we got the call.

Here’s the part we would add today.

We loved the location so much that we eventually tore the house down and built a new one on the same lot. That’s how strongly we felt about it. No regrets then, no regrets now.

On the flip side, house people usually have more options. If you’re flexible on where you land, you can be more selective about what you land in. But that doesn’t mean it’s a free pass. There are still a few traps to avoid.

If you’re a house buyer, give yourself some guardrails. You don’t need to lock into one neighborhood, but you also don’t want to be zig zagging all over the city every weekend. Pick two or three areas that actually support your day to day life and start there.

And don’t ignore location entirely just because the house feels like a win. It will matter again someday when you sell. It always does.
For example, if you get a lot more space on a busy street because the value feels great, just remember the next buyer is going to do that same math. In a market where buyers have options, homes in challenging locations are usually the first to feel it.

Now, if you’re a location buyer, the game is different.

You have to get crystal clear on your must haves. Not your wish list. Not your “this would be nice.” Your true, non negotiable list.
Because if you’re set on a tight area, you’re almost certainly going to give something up. That might be square footage, updates, or both.

We lived that firsthand. We went from a fully remodeled kitchen to one that hadn’t been touched since the early 90s. And it was still the right move for us because we got the location we wanted.

So if your must have list keeps growing, it’s worth asking yourself a simple question. What am I actually willing to trade to get this location?

If the answer is nothing, then you’ve got two options. Expand your search or get really comfortable being patient.

And one more thing for location buyers.

Don’t try to go it alone.

A lot of people think they can just put the word out and something will pop up. Occasionally, that happens. More often, it doesn’t.
If you’re trying to land something in a tight pocket, you need someone working that area every day. Someone who knows the agents, knows the inventory, and hears about things before they hit the market.

That’s where having the right Realtor actually matters.

At the end of the day, there’s no right or wrong answer here. But there is a right answer for you.
Figure out if you’re a house person or a location person before you sell. It will save you time, stress, and a lot of second guessing.
And if you’re like us, don’t be surprised if you end up betting on location and doubling down on it later.

Follow Close-In KC on Instagram
Close-In KC is your window into the neighborhoods that define Kansas City’s urban/suburban edge: Prairie Village, Brookside, Waldo, West Plaza, and beyond. Local homes, local stories, favorite hangouts and restaurants, and the everyday vibe of the places that make KC feel like home. Click Here!