Lawsuit alleges Olathe nonprofit’s negligence led to minor patient’s rape

The suit, filed in March, accuses the residential treatment facility Kids TLC of having a lack of supervision, leading to the minor's assault.

A lawsuit filed against an Olathe psychiatric residential treatment facility for children asserts that a woman with multiple disabilities was assaulted by other residents under the facility’s care.

The suit, filed in Johnson County District Court on March 5 by “Jane Doe,” accuses Kids TLC of negligence and disability discrimination.

Four Kids TLC staff members are named specifically as defendants in the suit: President and CEO Erin Dugan, Chief Clinical Program Officer John Laffoon, Director of Operations Devin Burgin and Lucinda Whitney, an advanced practice registered nurse.

Doe’s attorneys, Tammy Meyer and Catie Daly from Metzger Rosta LLP, say Kids TLC failed to properly care for and protect Doe from harm.

“There is not the level of supervision and protection of the residents that we would truly hope there would be or any parent would hope would exist,” Daly said.

Kids TLC and their attorneys did not respond for a request for comment at the time of publication.

The incidents

A welcome sign at the Kids TLC campus.
A welcome sign at the Kids TLC campus. Photo credit Kate Mays.

According to court documents, Doe was 15 when she was admitted to Kids TLC in March of 2022. Doe has several mental illnesses and required a high level of supervision and clinical care that her family was unable to provide.

The lawsuit states that her disabilities made her susceptible to sexual victimization which warranted increased supervision and safety protocols.

In April of 2022, Doe was placed in a “saferoom” after being found exposing her chest to another resident.

“This unsafe behavior that Jane exhibited should have placed the Facility and its staff on heightened alert that she was at an increased risk of sexual exploitation and assault,” the complaint reads.

Instead, the suit alleges, that night Doe was left alone while using the bathroom, giving a male resident the opportunity to rape her. The male resident had previously been charged with battery six times.

Court documents say staff are supposed to “maintain sight or sound observation at all times.”

“The Facility’s failure to supervise Jane and Male Resident 1, despite knowing Jane’s heightened vulnerability and her recent safety incident, as well as Male Resident 1’s extensive history of criminal battery charges, was inexcusable and demonstrated the Facility’s utter disregard for Jane’s safety,” the suit states.

Doe’s attorneys say that when she reported the incident to staff the next day, they waited over an hour to call the police.

Burgin allegedly instructed staff to not alert Doe’s parents, who didn’t find out until the Olathe Police Department contacted them. Kids TLC investigated the incident and determined the act was consensual.

In the aftermath of the incident, Kids TLC created a safety plan for Doe that the lawsuit asserts was “ineffective.”

Part of the plan was to keep Doe at least 6 feet away from other residents. In August of 2022, a second male resident was seen sexually touching Doe, but that staff said the assault wasn’t “intense” enough to warrant an investigation.

The next day, Doe and the second male resident were left alone in adjacent bathrooms. Court documents say he then raped her.

Doe was found huddled in a corner “acting strangely.”

She was taken to Children’s Mercy and screened positive for a suicide risk.

The suit claims Kids TLC acted negligently by not adequately supervising Doe, properly training employees and adding to her emotional distress. It also says they discriminated against Doe by not accommodating her disabilities which made her susceptible to sexual victimization.

Doe is requesting a jury trial, which has not been scheduled.

Below is a copy of the lawsuit.

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

Not isolated incidents

Since news of the suit has come out, Doe’s attorneys say they have learned this was not an isolated incident at Kids TLC.

“We are receiving a flood of phone calls and social media posts from other former employees and residents there that this was an ongoing problem of lack of staffing and lack of training of the staff,” Meyer said.

She added that she spoke with one staff member who was brutally beaten by residents because there weren’t enough staff to take care of everyone.

“It is a huge problem that I think is just being uncovered now,” Meyer said.

Meyer and Daly encourage former or current residents or staff members who experienced abuse at Kids TLC to reach out.

Before you go...

Thanks for reading! If you value having an independent news outlet keeping tabs on local government, schools and taxes, we're asking you to contribute to our Education Reporting Fund.

Report for America pays for half of our K-12 beat reporter's salary. Donations from readers like you cover the other half.

Gifts of any size are greatly appreciated. And all donations are tax deductible.

Support Education Funding

About the author

Kate Mays
Kate Mays

Hi! I’m Kate Mays, and I cover Olathe for the Johnson County Post.

I grew up in Lenexa and graduated from Shawnee Mission Northwest. I earned a bachelor’s degree in journalism from the University of Kansas where I produced podcasts for 90.7 KJHK. I went on to get a master’s in journalism from New York University. Before joining the Post, I interned for the Kansas City Business Journal and KCUR and produced an investigative, true-crime podcast.

Have a story idea or a comment about our coverage you’d like to share? Email me at [email protected].

LATEST HEADLINES