Despite mother’s plea, Olathe schools sticks to controversial graduation policy

A petition calling for the policy to be reversed has gathered more than 6,100 signatures, but the board says graduations must balance remembrance with celebration.

Despite thousands of petition signatures and an emotional plea from a grieving mother, the Olathe school board will keep its policy on how deceased students are recognized at graduation.

In a letter on Monday, leadership from the Olathe Public Schools Board of Education defended the policy, which it adopted in February, outlining how schools can recognize students who die before graduation.

The statement came days after Olathe parent Amber Hartsook urged the board to amend the policy so families could choose whether their child’s name would be read aloud during a school’s graduation ceremony.

Hartsook’s son, Treyton Hartsook, was a senior at Olathe South High School when he died in a car crash this winter break.

“Instead of addressing graduation invitations and scurrying for the final touches of a graduation party, I’m here to address policy,” Hartsook told the board at its May 7 meeting.

The board’s letter Monday acknowledged the grief surrounding student deaths but said graduation ceremonies should balance memorials with celebrating graduates.

“The purpose of the policy is to create an approach that is consistent and mindful of the many difficult situations that families and school communities may face over time as it relates to student loss,” the letter, which was signed by Board President Stacey Yurkovich and Vice President Julie Steele, said.

Petition calls for names to be read aloud

The debate centers on Policy JP, approved by the board 7-0 on Feb. 5. The policy says high school principals should meet with the families of deceased students and offer several recognition options, including an honor diploma awarded outside the ceremony and inclusion in the printed graduation program’s “In Memory Of” section.

It adds that the principals can discuss other non-graduation recognitions, as well.

Last Thursday, Hartsook addressed the board in an emotional plea to have her son’s name read aloud at Olathe South’s graduation, which is this coming Saturday, May 16.

She said the recently adopted policy doesn’t “consider the complexity of loss and grief.”

“Grief is not a one-size-fits-all. What feels honoring and healing to one family may feel different to another,” she said.

Hartsook created an online petition at Change.org ahead of the meeting to get the board to reconsider. As of Tuesday, it had received more than 6,100 signatures.

Policy discussion

Board member Robert Kuhn proposed an amendment to the policy before the vote in February that would include reading the child’s name during roll call and putting their picture on the Jumbotron. The amendment failed 4-3.

At that February meeting, Yurkovich said the policy was developed by a committee that included all five high school principals, a parent from each high school, two mental health professionals and herself.

Two of the parents on the committee had deceased children. According to Yurkovich, those parents said it would be too difficult for their children’s names to be read.

“This is where the committee landed, and I think we need to trust the work of people we bring together when we ask them to provide us a recommendation,” she said.

Board member Claire Reagan spoke in support of the policy.

“Graduations are a celebration,” she said in February. “And grief complicates that.”

Monday’s board letter also outlined several ways before and during the graduation ceremony the district already recognizes students who have died, including:

  • Posthumous diplomas
  • Memorial acknowledgements during graduation ceremonies
  • Photo tributes in pre-ceremony videos
  • Scholarship presentations
  • Moments of silence during school and graduation events
  • Permanent memorials
  • Student-led remembrance activities

The district said those recognitions honor deceased students “while also supporting the individual desires and capacity of grieving classmates, parents and staff members.”

“Policy JP regarding student deaths and graduation recognition was not created casually or without empathy,” the letter reads.

Still, Hartsook told board members that omitting students’ names from commencement ceremonies can add to their families’ grief.

“What should have been a quiet moment of recognition of his existence and accomplishment for those of us who knew and continue to love Treyton shouldn’t be taken away,” she said.

Before you go...

Thanks for reading! If you value having an independent news outlet keeping tabs on local government, schools and taxes, we're asking you to contribute to our Education Reporting Fund.

Report for America pays for half of our K-12 beat reporter's salary. Donations from readers like you cover the other half.

Gifts of any size are greatly appreciated. And all donations are tax deductible.

Support Education Funding

About the author

Kate Mays
Kate Mays

Hi! I’m Kate Mays, and I cover Olathe for the Johnson County Post.

I grew up in Lenexa and graduated from Shawnee Mission Northwest. I earned a bachelor’s degree in journalism from the University of Kansas where I produced podcasts for 90.7 KJHK. I went on to get a master’s in journalism from New York University. Before joining the Post, I interned for the Kansas City Business Journal and KCUR and produced an investigative, true-crime podcast.

Have a story idea or a comment about our coverage you’d like to share? Email me at [email protected].

LATEST HEADLINES