Lenexa City Council votes down censure of four members over open meetings violations

The Lenexa City Council was split over whether to further sanction councilmembers who violated KOMA.

Emotions ran high at a Lenexa City Council meeting as city leaders addressed five councilmembers’ previous open meetings violations, but avoided censuring them.

On Tuesday at the Lenexa City Council meeting, Mayor Julie Sayers kicked off a lengthy discussion concerning a possible censure of four city councilmembers after Kansas Attorney General Kris Kobach ruled that they had broken the Kansas Open Meetings Act, or KOMA, a state law that requires meetings of state and local public agencies to be open and transparent to the public.

“We take this matter seriously, as we do take our responsibility to comply with the law,” she said. 

A censure reprimands an individual or individuals of a governing body for inappropriate conduct and creates a public record condemning the conduct, said Sean McLaughlin, Lenexa city attorney. It does not remove them from office or carry other legal penalties.

The councilmembers include Courtney Eiterich, Christopher Herron, John Michael Handley and Chelsea Williamson, who engaged in conversations in a private text message thread. Herron and Williamson met with Councilmember Bill Nicks in person in February before voting on a rezoning ordinance and a preliminary plan for the Clear Creek Subdivision proposed by Habitat for Humanity, causing him to also be in violation of KOMA.

“It is my opinion that having a group chat with four members and meeting with multiple members outside of council to discuss an open agenda item both fail to meet that standard,” Sayers said on Tuesday.

At a city council meeting on Nov. 3, Nicks suggested that city staff and the governing body look into censuring the other four councilmembers, who he referred to as “The texters.”

“This violation goes, I think, to the heart of trust between Lenexa residents and her elected governing body … That trust has been broken,” Nicks said at the previous meeting. 

When discussion of the KOMA violation continued at Tuesday’s city council meeting, Councilmember Mark Charlton made a motion to censure the city councilmembers, with it seconded by Nicks.

“I’m making it my mission to help turn things around, restore our reputation, and move forward. As Bill noted at our last city council meeting, we must take meaningful steps so that Lenexa residents can begin to regain trust in their elected governing body,” he said.

The motion failed 2-5, with Councilmembers Avery Bell, Herron, Williamson, Handley and Mayor Sayers in dissent. Councilmembers Craig Denny and Eiterich were absent.

All councilmembers, including those up for censure, were permitted to vote.

Someone from the public demanded that those up for censure recuse themselves. Mayor Sayers said that if the four councilmembers recused themselves, then only three councilmembers plus the mayor would be present to vote, falling short of the necessary quorum to conduct business.

Additionally, the result of the motion to censure would have resulted in a 2-2 tie, if the councilmembers up for censure had recused themselves.

How they voted:

• Mayor Julie Sayers: No

• Avery Bell: No

• Mark Charlton: Yes

• Craig Denny: Absent

• Courtney Eiterich (up for censure): Absent

• John Michael Handley (up for censure): No

• Chris Herron (up for censure): No

• Bill Nicks: Yes

• Chelsea Williamson (up for censure): No

While a majority of the city council was against the censure, Charlton said censuring was a way to bring back trust in city government and force his colleagues to admit that they sullied Nicks’ reputation. He noted that he and Nicks are cousins.

“[What] disgusts me the most about this situation is that nearly 50 years of service to the city, Bill Nicks’ integrity has been called into question, and I’m not sure there’s another Lenexan who has shown greater integrity or dedication to our community than Bill. He is one of the primary reasons this city has thrived for decades,” he said.

The councilmembers privately discussed upcoming vote

Lenexa text message
Text message conversations between Lenexa city councilmembers. Image via Kansas Attorney General Kris Kobach’s office.

In Kobach’s ruling, Kobach said that Williamson, Eiterich, Herron and Handley engaged in private discussions in a text message group and that Herron and Williamson met with Nicks in person in February before voting on a rezoning ordinance and a preliminary plan for the Clear Creek Subdivision proposed by Habitat for Humanity.

After their meeting with Nicks, Herron and Williamson relayed information from it back to the text message chain with Eiterich and Handley, in an apparent attempt to see if the project had enough votes to pass.

On Feb. 17, the Lenexa City Council voted 7-2 in favor of three different measures to approve the Habitat project. Nicks, along with Councilmember Mark Charlton, voted in dissent on all three items.

As part of being sanctioned by the attorney general, the five councilmembers had to complete one hour of KOMA training and provide written certification of its completion. They also had to agree to cease and desist from future KOMA violations.

The four councilmembers, other than Nicks, also had to pay a $50 civil fine, which had to come out of the councilmembers’ own pockets and not from public funds. Nicks was excluded from that sanction because Kobach said Nicks was unaware of the text message group.

“The five members involved cooperated fully with that process and have completed the assigned corrective measures,” Sayers said at Tuesday’s meeting. 

Beyond the punishment Kobach’s office issued, Sayers acknowledged Nicks’ call to censure.

“I believe that we happen to have an opportunity to lead by example this evening. We can acknowledge that mistakes were made, offer each other grace, and move forward with actions that will speak for themselves in reaffirming our commitment to doing what is right. That is the Lenexa way,” she said. 

Councilmembers respond to violation

John Michael Handley is running for a full term to the Ward 1 seat on the Lenexa City Council after the city council appointed him in January 2025.
Councilmember John Michael Handley at a candidate forum when he was running for his current seat. File photo.

Councilmember Handley responded to the KOMA violation with an apology.

“I sincerely apologize to the citizens of Lenexa, to my fellow government body members, and to city staff. I did not meet the expectations that are set for us. I’ve taken full responsibility for my consequences. I’m grateful for the opportunity to continue to serve to try to rebuild some of that trust,” he said. 

Williamson admitted she was at fault and said she was committed to learn from the mistake.

“I sincerely regret that a violation occurred. I do make mistakes. I take those mistakes and I learn from them, and I learned how not to repeat the same ones again. I’ve always taken that position in my life, personally and professionally, and I take that here,” she said. 

Councilmember Herron, who previously issued a written apology in the Johnson County Post, did not speak.

When the vote to censure was brought up, Bell said he was against censuring his colleagues.

“I am of the opinion that a censure sends the wrong message. Actually, I believe that the state has already made that decision, and our councilmembers have taken accountability, and I would like to move on and move past this,” he said. 

Several residents rail against censure failing

Lenexa resident Herron
A Lenexa resident chides Councilmember Chris Herron. Photo credit Andrew Gaug.

Ten other residents spoke at the meeting, with nine saying explicitly that they favor punishing the four city councilmembers.

“We talked a lot about accountability tonight, and yet you voted against it. Your actions previous to this, with your texting, were confirmed this evening by your vote. You don’t believe in accountability,” said Lenexa resident Laura Owen. 

Several residents told the city council that they hope all of the four councilmembers are voted out when their terms are up.

“This is sickening, people. We have to change, and God, I hope there’s some changes at the next couple of elections, because I can’t do this. I’ve been a resident here since 2006, and it just makes me sick,” said Lenexa resident Kevin Cauley.

Lenexa resident Andy Keith, the one person from the public who didn’t explicitly say he supported censure, instead used his time to say the Habitat project would help address housing affordability in the city.

What’s next

When issuing her vote against censuring the four city councilmembers, Sayers said she hopes everyone can learn this violation.

“What I would like to make clear that it is not OK to have private meetings with other councilmembers, where the substantive content of an application … is discussed individually among possible business,” she said. 

Before you go...

Thanks for reading! If you value having an independent news outlet keeping tabs on local government, schools and taxes, we're asking you to contribute to our Education Reporting Fund.

Report for America pays for half of our K-12 beat reporter's salary. Donations from readers like you cover the other half.

Gifts of any size are greatly appreciated. And all donations are tax deductible.

Support Education Funding

About the author

Andrew Gaug
Andrew Gaug

? Hi! I’m Andrew Gaug, and I cover Shawnee and Lenexa for the Johnson County Post.

I received my bachelor’s degree in journalism from Kent State University and started my career as a business reporter for The Vindicator in Youngstown, Ohio.

I spent 14 years as a multimedia reporter for the St. Joseph News-Press before joining the Post in 2023.

Have a story idea or a comment about our coverage you’d like to share? Email me at [email protected].

Previous article

LATEST HEADLINES