Olathe OKs 64 townhomes on vacant lot where retail ‘dream’ never came true

The 5-2 council vote overrode the planning commission and months of neighborhood opposition to make way for a residential development at 119th and Lone Elm.

For nearly six months, Olathe residents, developers and leaders debated over the best use of a vacant nearly eight-acre lot at 119th Street and Lone Elm Road.

On Tuesday, that discussion came to an end when the Olathe City Council voted 5-2 to approve rezoning the land from a Neighborhood Center designation to R-3, for low-density residential projects to make room for a new townhome development.

How they voted:

Mayor John Bacon: Yes
Dean Vakas: Yes
LeEtta Felter: Yes
Robyn Essex: No
Matthew Schoonover: Yes
Kevin Deneault: Yes
Jeff Creighton: No

The vote clears the way for Lone Elm Townhomes, a 10-building, 64-unit development northeast of the intersection. It also ends the lengthy dispute over whether the site should remain reserved for future commercial development or used for housing.

Vocal opposition

The project has faced significant opposition since it was first proposed last year.

In December, the Olathe Planning Commission unanimously recommended denying the zoning request, saying the project doesn’t align with the city’s comprehensive plan.

That decision was met with cheers from nearby residents who were concerned about traffic and having their neighborhood’s amenities used by residents of the townhomes.

The next month, councilmembers remanded the plan back to city staff, asking developers to work with neighbors and explore the possibility of adding commercial elements.

In March, developers met with representatives from The Retreat at Foxfield Village HOA and the Foxfield Master HOA, two communities that sit adjacent to the proposed site.

The developer, the New Bedford Land Development Company, agreed to reduce the project from 71 to 64 townhomes, add an access drive on Lone Elm and design the buildings in the same architectural style as nearby neighborhoods.

Still, developers didn’t add any commercial elements to the plan, so city staff continued to recommend denial.

Staff argued that the 119th Street extension project, which will connect a gap between Northgate and Woodland roads, will lead to more traffic and visibility, so the site should be preserved for future retail development.

Developers disagreed

A green, empty lot.
The townhomes would be at the northeast corner of 119th Street and Lone Elm Road. Image via Google Maps.

Attorney Curtis Holland, who represents the developer, told the council in January the property has been marketed for commercial development for more than 20 years, but no one has expressed interest.

“Holding this property hostage for some dream of retail to show up at this seven-acre corner, this little small piece of property, is really not a good idea in our opinion,” said Holland in January.

At Tuesday’s meeting, Holland said they didn’t try to incorporate any commercial elements because that would be a “wasted effort.”

Councilmembers ultimately decided the city has a greater need for expanding the city’s affordable housing options than a possible commercial development.

“I was hoping to see a little bit more what you could come up with on the commercial side,” Councilmember Kevin Deneault said on Tuesday. “That being said, this is housing. It’s not really big, expensive homes. So I’m happy there’s something presented that can add some housing that some people can afford that aren’t making a ton of money.”

Developers have not stated if the townhomes will be rented or for sale. They’ve also not released any pricing details.

Councilmember Robyn Essex, who voted against the rezoning, said she remains concerned about the loss of commercial opportunities in that part of Olathe.

“It just breaks my heart that we are pushing out commercial more and more every day,” Essex said.

Before you go...

Thanks for reading! If you value having an independent news outlet keeping tabs on local government, schools and taxes, we're asking you to contribute to our Education Reporting Fund.

Report for America pays for half of our K-12 beat reporter's salary. Donations from readers like you cover the other half.

Gifts of any size are greatly appreciated. And all donations are tax deductible.

Support Education Funding

About the author

Kate Mays
Kate Mays

Hi! I’m Kate Mays, and I cover Olathe for the Johnson County Post.

I grew up in Lenexa and graduated from Shawnee Mission Northwest. I earned a bachelor’s degree in journalism from the University of Kansas where I produced podcasts for 90.7 KJHK. I went on to get a master’s in journalism from New York University. Before joining the Post, I interned for the Kansas City Business Journal and KCUR and produced an investigative, true-crime podcast.

Have a story idea or a comment about our coverage you’d like to share? Email me at [email protected].

LATEST HEADLINES